Carve a Jill o Lantern. Carve a pumpkin to look like a feminized Misha Collins. Bonus points for realism.
Now, many people on my flist are pretty damn amazing pumpkin carvers. I am not one of them. I think I *could* be, given some time and some pratice (and some tools that are not 1 old steak knife). That said, I'm pretty damn happy with how this turned out.
I also had to google Misha Collins, because I'm ashamed to say that I've never seen the show supernatural. I honestly couldn't pick him out of a lineup. If we win this scavenger hunt, I'll have to buy all 304958304 seasons and hardline them so I don't look like a no-nothing dork.
( Jill O lantern ahoy and bonus pic of Misha if you also don't know what he looks like! )